Three suppliers quote you PVC film. One says USD 1.50/kg FOB, the second USD 1.72/kg CIF, the third USD 2.05/kg DDP. The instinct is to compare the numbers. That is exactly the wrong move, because the three prices cover three different amounts of the journey — and the cheapest headline is frequently the most expensive once the goods are in your warehouse. This guide breaks down what each term actually includes, gives you the arithmetic for delivered cost per kilogram, and shows which term to use at which stage of your buying.
1. Who is responsible for what
| Điều khoản | Seller pays | Risk passes to you | You pay |
|---|---|---|---|
| EXW | Nothing — goods at the factory door | At the factory | Everything: export clearance, inland, sea, duty |
| FOB | Inland to port, export clearance, loading on board | Once on board | Ocean freight, insurance, destination charges, duty |
| CIF | FOB + ocean freight + minimum insurance | Still once on board | Destination charges, duty, inland |
| DAP | Everything up to your door, except duty | At your door | Duty and import VAT |
| DDP | Everything including duty | At your door, duty paid | Nothing further — this is a delivered price |
Two details in that table decide most disputes. First, CIF transfers risk at the ship’s rail, not at your port. If the container is damaged in a storm you own the loss, even though you paid the seller for freight. Second, DDP makes the seller the importer of record, which is convenient but means the paperwork is in their name, not yours — relevant if you later need to claim preferential duty or prove origin.
2. Why a CIF price can be the more expensive one
Three mechanisms, all common:
- Freight markup. The seller buys ocean freight through their own forwarder and is free to add margin. On a 20 ft container the spread between a good contract rate and a marked-up one is often USD 300–600 — invisible inside a per-kilogram price.
- Minimum insurance. CIF requires cover at 110% of the CIF value under Institute Cargo Clauses (C) — the narrowest of the three standard clauses. It excludes theft, water damage and handling damage, which are precisely the risks a film shipment faces.
- Destination charges are not included. Terminal handling, deconsolidation, storage and documentation at your end are always yours. On LCL cargo these can add 15–25% to the freight line.
None of this makes CIF dishonest. It makes it opaque, and opacity is expensive when you are comparing three quotes.
3. The only number that matters: delivered cost per kilogram
delivered cost/kg = FOB price + freight/kg + insurance + duty + destination charges + inland
The freight component is where small orders get destroyed, because freight scales with volume and weight, not with value. Two worked examples, using a film at 0.30 mm, 1.37 m wide, 0.575 kg per metre:
| Scenario | Quantity | Freight share of cost |
|---|---|---|
| LCL, 1.000 kg, Southeast Asia | ~1.7 m³ effective, one pallet-plus | Often 25–40% of the goods value — the single biggest reason small orders look uncompetitive |
| FCL, 20 ft, ~8.000 kg | 10–11 pallets at 1200×1000 mm | Typically 5–10% of goods value; the freight per kg collapses |
The commercial conclusion is blunt: a 1.000 kg order is rarely a freight-optimised order. If it is a trial, accept that and budget for it. If it is your regular buying size, your cost problem is the order size, not the unit price.
4. Where the hidden costs sit in each term
| Cost | FOB | CIF | DDP |
|---|---|---|---|
| Export clearance | Seller | Seller | Seller |
| Ocean freight markup | You negotiate directly | Hidden, seller’s margin | Hidden, seller’s margin |
| Insurance quality | You choose the clause | Minimum ICC (C) | Seller’s choice, unknown |
| Destination THC & storage | You | You | Seller (usually baked in) |
| Import duty & VAT | You | You | Seller, recovered in price |
| Customs value declared | Real transaction value | Real transaction value | Opaque — ask for the declaration |
5. Which term to use, and when
There is a right answer for each stage of the relationship:
- First trial order (100–500 kg): use DDP if the supplier offers it, or express courier with freight prepaid. You are paying a premium for not having to learn import procedures on your smallest order.
- Second and third orders: move to FOB and appoint your own forwarder. You will see the real freight cost, you can consolidate with other suppliers, and you gain a second opinion on routing.
- Regular monthly volume: FOB with a contracted rate, reviewed quarterly. At this point freight becomes a line you manage, and the supplier’s markup on it is money you keep.
- CIF is a reasonable middle when you have no forwarder relationship yet but the volume is too large for courier — accept it, but ask for the freight and insurance breakdown in writing so you can benchmark next time.
6. Duty, origin and the paperwork that saves money
Film attracts duty in most markets, and the rate depends on the HS code and origin. Under RCEP and the China–ASEAN agreement, many Southeast Asian destinations apply preferential rates — often zero — provided you have the correct certificate of origin (Form E) issued by the Chinese authority. Two practical points:
- Ask the supplier to confirm the HS code they declare, and check it against your own customs broker’s classification. A mismatched code is a delay at best, a fine at worst.
- Under DDP the seller is the importer of record, so the preferential origin claim is theirs to make. If the duty saving matters to you, buy FOB or CIF and import in your own name.
Frequently asked questions
Is a DDP price always more expensive than FOB plus my own freight?
Usually yes, by the seller’s margin on freight plus duty handling. It is still worth using on a first order, because the cost of learning import clearance on a small shipment exceeds that margin. From the second order onward, compare it against FOB plus your forwarder’s quote.
Does CIF cover damage to the film in transit?
Only under Institute Cargo Clauses (C), which excludes handling damage, theft and water ingress. Film is vulnerable to all three. If you buy CIF, ask the seller to quote Clauses (A) instead, or insure the cargo yourself.
Can I mix terms on one order?
Not within a single shipment — one Incoterm per shipment. But you can buy FOB and instruct your forwarder to arrange insurance, which is the common compromise: you control the freight and the cover.
What is a realistic freight cost for 1.000 kg to Southeast Asia?
It moves with fuel, peak season and lane. Ask your forwarder for a rate valid 14 days and compare it against the supplier’s CIF delta — that difference is the markup you are being charged for convenience. Do not rely on any figure older than a month.
Should I worry about the container being opened at the destination?
Yes, indirectly. Film rolls are heavy and are handled with clamps; corner crush and edge damage in consolidated cargo are the most common claims. Photograph the container seal on arrival before opening, and specify corner protection and edge boards on the packing list.
Bước tiếp theo: we quote FOB, CIF and DDP on request, and we will show the freight and insurance lines separately rather than hiding them in the unit price. If you are planning your first container, read how to choose pallets for film rolls và what lead time actually means before you fix a delivery date.
